Protecting Bali from Foreign Investment Invasion: Examining FDI Restrictions from a Legal and Economic Justice Perspective

BALI – The Bali Provincial Government’s decision to close licensing access for Foreign Direct Investment (PMA) in 18 business sectors through the Online Single Submission (OSS) system has become one of the most attention-grabbing investment policies in recent years.

This policy has drawn mixed reactions. Some view the move as a form of protectionism against local businesses, while others see it as a negative signal for the investment climate.

However, when examined from both a legal and economic perspective, this policy is not a rejection of foreign investment. Rather, it represents an attempt to correct investment practices deemed to have deviated from the original purpose of foreign investment in Indonesia. The Bali Provincial Government stated that the restrictions were imposed after it discovered indications of misuse of the OSS mechanism by a number of foreign direct investment companies (PMAs) to enter business sectors that have historically been the economic space for local MSMEs.

Thus, the real question is not whether Bali is anti-investment, but rather how Indonesian investment law can create a balance between investor protection and the protection of local community interests.

The Nature of Foreign Investment in the Indonesian Legal System

Law No. 25 of 2007 concerning Investment explicitly positions foreign investment as an instrument of national development. The presence of PMA is expected to bring capital, technology, innovation, improved human resource quality, and create jobs.

This means that foreign investment is not intended to take over business areas that are economically viable for local communities, particularly the micro, small, and medium enterprise (MSME) sector. This philosophy aligns with Article 33 of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, which stipulates that the economy is structured as a joint venture based on the principle of kinship for the greatest possible prosperity of the people.

Therefore, foreign investment should ideally be directed towards sectors that have high added value ( high value investment ), require technology, large capital, and are able to increase the competitiveness of the national economy.

Why is Bali Implementing Restrictions?

The Bali Provincial Government’s evaluation revealed a tendency for foreign direct investment (PMA) to enter low- and medium-risk business sectors, which only require a Business Identification Number (NIB), without adequate investment verification. This loophole is exploited by some foreign investors to operate small businesses that could actually be run by locals, even in some cases using virtual office addresses.

The 18 KBLI that are restricted are as follows:

  1. code 55110 Star Hotel (building area < 6,000 m²),
  2. code 68111 Real Estate owned or rented,
  3. code 55120 Melati Hotel (building area < 6,000 m²),
  4. code 70209 Other Management Consulting Activities,
  5. code 77100 car, bus, truck and similar rentals,
  6. code 47711 Retail Trade of Clothing, and
  7. code 47511 Retail Trade of Textiles.
  8. code 77311 Motorbike Rental Without Option Rights,
  9. code47249 Other Food Retail Trade,
  10. code 47991 Mobile Retail Trade of Food Commodities from Agricultural Products,
  11. code 55900 Provision of Other Accommodation,
  12. code 56303 Drinking House/Cafe,
  13. code 56305 Traditional Medicine House/Shop,
  14. code 14120 Tailoring and Custom Clothing Making.
  15. code 93111 Stadium Facilities,
  16. code 93116 Fitness Center Facilities ,
  17. code 93191 Sports Activities Promoter,
  18. Code 70204 Industrial Management Consulting Activities,
    (data source: oss.go.id)

This policy does not revoke existing business permits, but rather closes access to new permit applications for PMA in these sectors until further regulations are in place.

Investment Law Perspective

From the perspective of state administrative law, the government has the authority to evaluate the licensing system if it finds misuse of regulations that has the potential to harm the public interest.

This principle is known as the principle of public interest , which is the basis for the formation of various public policies.

Furthermore, modern investment law focuses not only on the ease of doing business but also on the quality of investment . International organizations such as the OECD and UNCTAD encourage developing countries to prioritize investments that provide long-term economic benefits over those that only pursue short-term gains.

In the context of Bali, these restrictions can be seen as an effort to maintain investment quality so that it remains in line with the characteristics of the regional economy, which relies on tourism, culture, and MSMEs.

Impact on the Property Sector

As a property business actor, I believe this policy should not be interpreted as a threat to investors.

What is restricted is not property investment as a whole, but rather certain business activities that use the PMA scheme in business sectors that are deemed to have entered the local community’s economic space.

Investors who truly want to build large-scale hotels, integrated tourism areas, creative economy centers, health facilities, education facilities, or other strategic projects still have investment space in accordance with statutory regulations.

In fact, this policy provides certainty that foreign investment is directed towards productive projects that provide high added value for Bali.

Maintaining a Balance between Investment and Social Justice

Investment is indeed a driver of economic growth. However, economic growth without justice will only result in inequality.

The state has a constitutional obligation to ensure that the benefits of development can be felt by the wider community, not just by capital owners.

Bali has long been a highly sought-after international investment destination. However, if small businesses like vehicle rentals, retail trade, cafes, and simple services begin to be dominated by foreign direct investment (FDI), the growth space for local MSMEs will shrink.

In the long term, this condition could actually erode the economic resilience of the Balinese people themselves.

The restriction of foreign direct investment (FDI) to 18 business sectors in Bali cannot be simply understood as an anti-investment policy. Rather, this measure represents a form of investment management to ensure it remains aligned with constitutional objectives, investment law, and the principles of sustainable development.

Indonesia needs foreign investment. But it also needs investment that is high-quality, responsible, respects national laws, protects MSMEs, and provides tangible benefits to the community.

Ultimately, sound investment is not one that dominates the entire economic space, but rather one that grows with the community, strengthens the local economy, and becomes part of equitable national development. Bali is sending an important message that openness to investment must always go hand in hand with protecting the interests of the people.

By: Rudi Sembiring Meliala, S.Th., MH
Property Entrepreneur | Academic